Bugging Devices Found at Italian Yacht Builder Ferretti

The Italian Ferretti Group was the setting for a spy-vs-spy scenario that reportedly included private detectives shadowing an executive of the Italian builder’s primary Chinese investor and recording devices hidden in several offices, according to Bloomberg. 

The discovery of this board-level surveillance has prompted two criminal cases, now in the hands of Italian prosecutors. In April 2024, Xu Xinyu, an executive director at Ferretti SpA, noticed two men in an SUV outside Ferretti’s headquarters in Milan... 

Xu also observed the pair following him while visiting hotels in the city, Bloomberg reported. He hired a counter-surveillance company, which reportedly found a listening device and signal amplifier hidden in his office. Other devices were found in the offices of Ferretti’s Chinese-Italian translator and board secretary.

...the Ferretti Group filed its own complaint... “Ferretti SpA considers itself an aggrieved party, having been wronged by the unlawful and improper installation of surveillance devices within its offices,” the statement said. more

AI Can't Protect It's IP Alone - It Needs TSCM

From her new book, Empire of AI, by journalist Karen Hao.

Sam Altman Asked for a Countersurveillance Audit of OpenAI

Altman himself was paranoid about people leaking information. He privately worried about Neuralink staff, with whom OpenAI continued to share an office, now with more unease after Elon Musk’s departure. Altman worried, too, about Musk, who wielded an extensive security apparatus including personal drivers and bodyguards. 

Keenly aware of the capability difference, Altman at one point secretly commissioned an electronic countersurveillance audit in an attempt to scan the office for any bugs that Musk may have left to spy on OpenAI. more

Got worries about your intellectual property? Get MA.

I Asked AI How to Bug a Room...

I asked AI how to bug this room. It did. 

Then, it tried to take my job! https://lnkd.in/eUCaiCDj

Former Council Candidate Bugs Town Hall

FL - A former Southwest Ranches council candidate is accused of planting a recording device in Town Hall and sharing the information with a business owner locked in a lawsuit with the city, according to court documents and town officials.

John Garate, 50, was arrested by Davie police on Dec. 19 after they caught him leaving Town Hall with a recording device he secretly placed in a conference room the day before, according to an arrest report.

His arrest was the culmination of an investigation that started two weeks earlier, when town officials called police to report their belief that someone had recorded a Dec. 4 closed-door meeting in that conference room. The purpose of that meeting was to discuss strategies for ongoing civil cases.

Police reviewed Town Hall surveillance footage and identified Garate as someone who walked into the building on Dec. 5, entered the conference room, and walked out with “something in his hands,” according to the arrest report.... Police planted their own recording device ahead of a second closed-door meeting scheduled for Dec. 18.

...the recording shows Garate entering the conference two hours before the Dec. 18 meeting. After he left Town Hall, but before the meeting, police checked the conference room and “verified that a device was placed on the bookshelf.”

The next morning, after the meeting, Garate returned to Town Hall, entered the conference room, picked up the device and was stopped by police as he was leaving. “During the search incident to arrest, in the defendant’s pocket was a black device with a USB attachment,” the police report states.

John Garate, 50, was arrested by Davie police on Dec. 19 after they caught him leaving Town Hall with a recording device he secretly placed in a conference room the day before, according to an arrest report. more

You might also be interested in: The World’s Smallest Voice Recorder?

Hackers are Taking Aim at Board Directors

Well-known CEOs and executives aren’t the only potential victims of hacks and threats from criminals. Board directors also have to be vigilant, according to Jason Lish, the global chief information security officer at Cisco.

“Often times they’re targets, especially for public companies, where their profiles are out there,” he said during a virtual conversation on Thursday hosted by Fortune in partnership with Diligent for The Modern Board series.

Lish added that he’s even seen an increase in the mailing of physical ransom letters to board directors and company executives. “How do they stay protected in their personal lives?” he said. “Because threat actors will try to do reconnaissance.” more

TSCM is the corporate counterespionage measure you need.

2025 Canadian Technical Security Conference (CTSC)

Conference Dates
Tuesday May 06, 2025 to Thursday May 08, 2025
Arrival Monday May 05, 2025

Conference Venue
Banff Centre for Professional Development
Kinnear Centre for Innovation
107 Tunnel Mountain Drive, Banff, Alberta Canada T1L 1H5

Conference Theme:
The Future of Technical Security: Adapting to a Changing Threat Landscape
Defensive resources, tools, countermeasures, and technologies are available. That is why, you need to attend the Canadian Technical Security Conference to hone an up-to-date awareness of the threat environment, countermeasures, tools and a better understanding how to make the best use of them. Moreover, not only will you learn from experts but you can become part of a community that pulls together against the threat operators to share information and best practices.

A very worthwhile event for TSCM colleagues. more

TSCM Tech: Another Step Closer to the Holy Grail - Visualizing RF

Holo-Scan: 3D Scanner with Augmented Reality (AR) Headset
The Holo-Scan is a 3D electromagnetic field mapping system in augmented reality (AR) compatible with various laboratory equipment such as spectrum analyzers, vector network analyzers (VNA) or specific probes (Narda, Wavecontrol…). Unlimited frequency band depending on the instruments used.  The data is then exported in .lxd format and directly analyzed in the online viewer. more

Looking forward to the day this can be direct coupled to an SDR and my Vision Pro. ~Kevin

TSCM Tech - Coating Hides Temp Changes from IR Cameras

An ultrathin coating developed by University of Wisconsin–Madison engineers upends a ubiquitous physics phenomenon of materials related to thermal radiation: The hotter an object gets, the brighter it glows.

The new coating — engineered from samarium nickel oxide, a unique tunable material — employs a bit of temperature trickery.

“This is the first time temperature and thermal light emission have been decoupled in a solid object. We built a coating that ‘breaks’ the relationship between temperature and thermal radiation in a very particular way,” says Mikhail Kats, a UW–Madison professor of electrical and computer engineering. more

The Last Thing I Wanted to See...

In the parking lot,
after completing a TSCM bug sweep...

FutureWatch: Visualizing Radio Waves to Detect Eavesdropping Bugs

If you could see radio waves it would make finding your misplaced mobile phone easier. It would also make finding eavesdropping bugs and covert spy cameras easier to find, too.

We are not quite there yet, but progress is being made. A French company, Luxondes, is working on this now. Their focus, however, is not consumer or TSCM oriented. The immediate profit market is product testing. 

In this video, they show a transmitting device being waved in front of a panel with 64 sensors operating between 50 MHz and 3 GHz. 

Being able to visualize radio waves is necessary for many reasons. As TSCM practitioners, we want this technology to evolve.  

• Initially, by developing a hand-held screen which can be moved around a room or vehicle. 
• Eventually, by developing a device—maybe a spatial headset—that displays radio-frequency energy as a 3-D fog, lidar-map the room, and document both for review and as evidence. 
• And, whenever possible, add AI capabilities. Determine the frequency. List what is legally allowed to use that frequency. Analyze and identify the waveform. Display the results, and highlight any anomalies. 

With any luck, REI is also working on this for us.

Free TSCM AI Knowledge Wiki

The website, counterespionage.net, provides a comprehensive range of resources related to Technical Surveillance Countermeasures (TSCM), which can be considered as a knowledge wiki for several reasons:

1. Informative Articles: It features detailed articles explaining what TSCM is and its importance in protecting corporate privacy and intellectual property. For example, the article on What Is TSCM? outlines the holistic approach needed for effective TSCM evaluations.

2. Free Resources: The site offers free TSCM security reports, publications, and videos that educate users about various aspects of surveillance and counter-surveillance techniques. You can find these resources in the TSCM Information section.

3. Guides and Tips: It includes practical guides such as the Security Director’s Guide to Discussing TSCM with Management and tips for businesses on counterespionage, which serve as valuable educational tools.

4. Case Studies and Testimonials: The website also shares case studies and client testimonials that provide real-world examples of TSCM applications, enhancing the learning experience for users.

5. FAQs and Expert Insights: The presence of a FAQ section allows users to get quick answers to common questions about TSCM, further contributing to its role as a knowledge base.

Overall, the combination of educational content, practical resources, and expert insights makes this website a valuable TSCM knowledge wiki. more

Trade Secret Cases On the Rise

Barnes & Thornburg LLP - Mitchell Berry

In recent years, there has been a noticeable uptick in trade secret litigation, signaling a shift in how businesses safeguard their valuable intellectual property...

Clients are increasingly turning to trade secrets as a means of protecting their innovations, particularly in sectors where rapid technological advancements and short product life cycles render patents less effective. Trade secrets offer perpetual protection as long as the information remains confidential, providing a valuable alternative for companies operating in dynamic and fast-paced markets.

The rise of trade secret litigation also highlights the need for robust internal policies and procedures to safeguard confidential information proactively. Companies must invest in measures such as employee training, restricted access controls, and non-disclosure agreements to mitigate the risk of inadvertent disclosure or theft of trade secrets. more

Did You Know: The legal system does not automatically protect Trade Secrets just on your say-so. You need to prove a history of special protections, like TSCM.

2024 TSCM Trend Analysis

TSCM Equipment Market Size, Share, Competitive Landscape and Trend Analysis Report by Type, by Product and by Industry Vertical: Global Opportunity Analysis and Industry Forecast, 2023-2032

Excerpt: "For instance, Murray Associates, an independent security consulting firm specializing in counterespionage consulting and information security for 40 years, provides TSCM and eavesdropping detection using real-time RF spectrum analysis, which is an advanced TSCM technology. 

In addition, Murray Associates, recently was the first non-government TSCM organization to offer advanced TSCM technology. The firm launched non-linear junction detection (NLJD) that can locate spy cams and other bugging devices even while they are turned off or out of power.

These factors result in innovation of highly discreet and capable modern surveillance technologies that are able to evade methods of traditional TSCM to meet new, emerging technical threats. The advanced TSCM equipment market is expected to grow at the highest CAGR." more

A Corporate New Year's Resolution - Detect Espionage Easily

Intelligence collection is a leisurely process. Enemies quietly collect long before they use. 

Until they use what they have gathered, no harm is done. Knowing this gives you the edge.

• Electronic Surveillance is not the goal. It is a means to an end.
• Electronic Surveillance is a key component of intelligence gathering.
• Electronic Surveillance is the one spy trick which is easily detectable, if you look for it.

Protection Requires Detection
Technical Surveillance Countermeasures (TSCM) audits exploit weaknesses inherent in electronic surveillance. Knowing you are being targeted provides you with time to counter - before your information is used against you; before harm is done.

All businesses need TSCM as their canary in the mine shaft. 

Click here to learn more... counterespionage.com

Why You Really Need a Technical Information Security Consultant

The non-existence of a trade secret asset: ‘confidential’ information
by R. Mark Halligan 

FisherBroyles LLP

For years, there has been a debate whether “confidential” information is analogous to a “trade secret.” It is not. Information is either protected as a “trade secret” or not protected as a “trade secret.” Any other characterization of “confidential” information undermines the protection of trade secret assets and interferes with lawful and fair business competition.

There is no such thing as non-trade secret “confidential” information.

There is no such thing as “confidential” information that does not rise to the level of a trade secret.

There is no middle ground: Either the information is a “trade secret” (and protectable) or not a trade secret (and not protectable).

A “trade secret” is an intellectual property asset that requires reasonable measures to protect the information as a “trade secret” and proof that such information derives an actual or potential economic advantage from the secrecy of the information. more

Your business is based on information and conversations considered confidential, sensitive, or intellectual property. These create your competitive advantage. No less important than trade secrets, and yet, not protected under trade secret law. 

So, what protection do you have? 

Start by adding a Technical Information Security Consultant to your team. Their proactive surveys can spot espionage issues like electronic eavesdropping, information security risks, and employee compliance with information security policies—before they become losses.

Corporate TSCM Information Security Inspections - Myths, Excuses & Reality

There are some myths and excuses that really need to be debunked.

(Not sure what a TSCM inspection is. Check here first.) 

TSCM SECURITY INSPECTION MYTHS and EXCUSES

Espionage is a Covert Act

Excuse: “I don’t see that we have a problem. No one is bugging our offices and boardroom.” 

 

Reality: The first rule of espionage is, “Be invisible.” You won’t know if you are being eavesdropped on if you never check.

Fear of being Labeled Paranoid

Myth: Peer pressure from upper management. 

 

Reality: Most top management appreciate proactive security thinking from their staff.

Lack of Awareness

Excuse: Yes. 

 

Reality: A lack of awareness of the risks associated with electronic eavesdropping, or the need for TSCM security inspections is common. Management may be unaware of TSCM as an available countermeasure.

Cost

Myth: TSCM inspections can be expensive. The costs involved in hiring a professional TSCM specialist, or purchasing specialized equipment, and conducting regular inspections can be a deterrent to scheduling TSCM inspections. 

 

Reality: Espionage losses are more expensive, much more. Hiring a TSCM specialist is very cost-effective, if you hire a competent firm. TSCM inspections are cheap insurance. Actually, better than insurance; TSCM can prevent the loss in the first place.

Perception of Low Risk

Excuse: Some businesses may believe that the risk of electronic eavesdropping is low in their industry or specific workplace. They might assume that their organization does not hold valuable or sensitive information that would attract eavesdroppers. 

 

Reality: Being “in business” means having a competitive advantage, and others do want it.

Lack of In-House Expertise

Excuse: Conducting TSCM inspections requires specialized knowledge and equipment. If a business does not have the expertise in-house they may choose not to pursue these inspections. 

 

Reality: Hiring an information security consultant–who has TSCM as their speciality–is the solution.

 

More TSCM Security Inspection Myths & Excuses

Fear of Disruption

Myth: TSCM security inspections can temporarily disrupt normal business operations. The process involves sweeping the premises, potentially causing interruptions or inconveniences to employees or ongoing activities. Some businesses might be reluctant to undergo such disruptions. 

 

Reality: Most inspections are conducted after business hours. When necessary, a TSCM team will assume the same dress and demeanor as employees, have a plausible reason for being in the area, and will work around employees so as not to disturb them.

Trust in Existing Security Measures

Excuse: Businesses may have confidence in their existing security measures, such as physical security, cybersecurity, or access controls. They might believe that these measures are sufficient to protect against eavesdropping and thus forego TSCM security inspections. 

 

Reality: Experience has shown that do-it-yourself security measures are never sufficient to protect against eavesdropping and other forms of information loss. TSCM inspections always identify vulnerabilities and provide recommendations for improvement.

Lack of Legal or Regulatory Requirements

Excuse: Depending on the industry or geographical location, there may be no legal or regulatory obligations that mandate TSCM inspections. In the absence of such requirements, businesses may choose not to prioritize these inspections. 

 

Reality: The financial success of a business should be a more effective motivator than a legal requirement.

Perception of Invasion of Privacy

Myth: TSCM security inspections are invasive or a breach of employee privacy. They might fear that conducting such inspections could harm employee morale or create an atmosphere of distrust. 

 

Reality: Employees appreciate security measures which protect their livelihood and personal privacy. When an employer demonstrates care for information security, employees will act more carefully too.

Limited Resources

Excuse: Small businesses or those with resource constraints may prioritize other operational needs over TSCM security inspections. They might allocate their limited resources to other critical areas or invest in measures they perceive as more immediate concerns. 

 

Reality: Defense is mandatory for survival. Budget waste and misallocation can usually fund TSCM security inspections without added expense, once corrected.

Overconfidence

Excuse: Some businesses might have a sense of overconfidence in their security measures, believing that they are already adequately protected against electronic eavesdropping. This false sense of security can lead to complacency and a disregard for TSCM inspections. 

 

Reality: These businesses are at-risk.

Carefully assess the risks in your workplace. Schedule TSCM security inspections, because… corporate espionage is not a myth.

###

Murray Associates is an independent technical information security consulting firm. They provide electronic surveillance detection and counterespionage services to business, government and at-risk individuals.

Headquartered in the New York metropolitan area, a Murray Associates team can assist you quickly, anywhere in the United States, and internationally.