Sunday, January 12, 2025
9th Circ. Upholds Ore. Ban On Secret Audio Recordings
A split en banc Ninth Circuit panel on Tuesday upheld as constitutional an Oregon law prohibiting secret audio recordings of people's conversations, ruling in a published opinion that the statute was narrowly tailored to Oregon's significant interest in ensuring its residents know when their conversations are recorded, even in public. more
Tuesday, October 22, 2024
Meanwhile, at my local restaurant...
Jacqueline Hindle, 49, who lost in June's hotly contested Republican primary for two Township Committee seats, and Christina Albrecht, 45, the wife of the other unsuccessful candidate, Ben Smith, have been charged by the Hunterdon County Prosecutor's Office with an alleged scheme to record a private conversation between Mayor Adam Mueller and Deputy Mayor Vincent Panico at The Rail restaurant in Whitehouse Station.
The two were charged with violating sections of the New Jersey Wiretapping and Electronic Surveillance Control Act. more
Wednesday, October 2, 2024
Mistress Recorded Trysts with Italian Minister on ‘Spy Glasses’
Gennaro Sangiuliano, the culture minister who is married, met Maria Rosaria Boccia, a former men’s fashion retailer from Pompeii, at a political rally a year ago.
She subsequently attended ministerial meetings, gained access to the Palazzo Montecitorio, home to one of Italy’s two parliamentary houses, and accompanied Sangiuliano, 62, at official events around the country, from Taormina in Sicily to Riva Ligure in Liguria.
Boccia has accused her former lover of misusing public funds to pay for her trips, providing access to confidential information and appointing her as an adviser despite a conflict of interest.
She has supported her assertions with audio recordings of phone calls with ministerial officials, screenshots of emails and flight tickets, and photos of confidential programmes for official events.
Throughout their affair she recorded an unknown number of private conversations, using her phone and a pair of Ray-Ban Stories sunglasses, which have a built-in camera and microphone. Footage taken also shows the corridors of the Palazzo Montecitorio, where it is forbidden to film. more
Friday, May 3, 2024
His Nickname is Mikey
Tuesday, August 15, 2023
He Hid a Tape Recorder in a Pen Cup...
...and caught the sheriff in a disturbing scandal.
A small-town paper takes on the county sheriff. The sheriff told staffers that anyone who spoke to the Gazette would be fired.
It is a long, complicated, and interesting story of a small town newspaper busting political corruption. Briefly, here is one of the methods used...
Two of the three commissioners—Robert Beck and Mark Jennings, the chairman—were present, along with the board’s executive assistant, Heather Carter. As they neared the end of the listed agenda, Bruce slipped a recording device disguised as a pen into a cup holder at the center of the conference table. “Right in front of ’em,” he bragged. He left, circling the block for the next several hours as he waited for the commissioners to clear out. When they did, he went back inside, pretended to review some old paperwork, and retrieved the recording device.
That night, after Gwen went to bed, Bruce listened to the audio, which went on for three hours and thirty-seven minutes. He heard other county officials enter the room, one by one—“Like, ‘Now is your time to see the king.’ ”
Maybe he got the pen in cup idea from here. Or, maybe this is an intuitively obvious spy trick. Would it have fooled you? more
Saturday, March 25, 2023
Bad Bunny - Not Your Recording - Bad Bunny
Monday, February 20, 2023
Green Bay City Hall Surveillance Recording
...obtained the city hall surveillance recordings through an open records request...to confirm Green Bay’s use of audio surveillance at city hall...
In the last week, the city denied requests to disable the microphones and delete any recordings...
One party consent is the law in Wisconsin. more
Thursday, February 16, 2023
Possible New Exception to the All Party Consent Wiretap Law
Thursday, October 6, 2022
Office Bugging Leak Inquiry—Given 7 Days to Submit Report
Wednesday, July 13, 2022
LAWS ON RECORDING CONVERSATIONS IN ALL 50 STATES
Individuals, businesses, and the government often have a need to record telephone conversations that relate to their business, customers, or business dealings.
Laws governing telephone call recording are typically found within state criminal statutes and codes because most states frame call recording as eavesdropping, wiretapping, or as a type of intercepted communication. State laws may not explicitly mention telephone call recording because of these technical definitions. Accordingly, counsel may need to infer when and under what circumstances a state permits telephone call recording by reviewing prohibited actions.
The big issue when it comes to recording someone is whether the jurisdiction you are in requires that you get the consent of the person or persons being recorded... more
Friday, July 2, 2021
Recording Conversations And Phone Calls - A Quick Primer
One-Party Consent
If the consent of one party is required, you can record a conversation if you’re a party to the conversation. If you’re not a party to the conversation, you can record a conversation or phone call provided one party consents to it after having full knowledge and notice that the conversation will be recorded...All-Party Consent
Twelve (12) states require the consent of everybody involved in a conversation or phone call before the conversation can be recorded. Those states are: California, Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Montana, Nevada, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania and Washington. These laws are sometimes referred to as “Two-Party” consent laws but, technically, require that all parties to a conversation must give consent before the conversation can be recorded.
Consent
What constitutes “consent” is also an issue of contention when you are considering recording a conversation. In some states, “consent” is given if the parties to the call are clearly notified that the conversation will be recorded, and they engage in the conversation anyway. Their consent is implied. For example, we have all experienced calling a customer service department only to hear a recorded voice warning, “This call may be recorded for quality assurance or training purposes.” It is usually a good practice for practitioners to let the witness know they are recording the call in order to accurately recall and commemorate the testimony being given – such as during the taking of a witness’ statement.
Exceptions
Nearly all states include an extensive list of exceptions to their consent requirements. Common exceptions found in a majority of states’ laws include recordings captured by police, court order, communication service providers, emergency services, etc...
Interstate/Multi-State Phone Calls
Telephone calls are routinely originated in one state and participated in by residents of another state. In conference call settings, multiple states (and even countries) could be participating in a telephone call which is subject to being recorded by one or more parties to the call. This presents some rather challenging legal scenarios when trying to evaluate whether a call may legally be recorded. A call from Pennsylvania to a person in New York involves the laws of both states. Which state’s laws apply and/or whether the law of each state must be adhered to are questions parties to a call are routinely faced with...
Federal Law
In most cases, both state and federal laws may apply. State laws are enforced by your local police department and the state’s attorney office. Federal wiretapping laws are enforced by the FBI and U.S. Attorney’s office. It is a federal crime to wiretap or to use a machine to capture the communications of others without court approval, unless one of the parties has given their prior consent. This means that if you are initiating a recording on a call that you are participating in, the other party does not need to be notified that the call is being recorded. It is likewise a federal crime to use or disclose any information acquired by illegal wiretapping or electronic eavesdropping. moreMore information on the laws in all 50 states regarding the recording of phone conversations found here.
Monday, April 12, 2021
Recording Calls Without Consent Still Illegal, California Supreme Court Rules
The court’s unanimous decision reverses the Fourth Appellate District’s opposite interpretation from 2019 that the law applies only to nonparties and does not forbid those on the call from recording each other without consent.
California’s penal code Section 632.7 makes it a crime to record or intercept a phone call “without the consent of all parties.”
This was the basis for a 2016 lawsuit by Jeremiah Smith, who claimed the loan provider LoanMe Inc. recorded him without his consent during an 18-second call in violation of Section 632.7. more
Wednesday, April 7, 2021
Coca-Cola Trade Secret Theft Underscores Importance of Early Detection
The value placed on the development of the stolen technologies is $119.6 million. Other affected companies include Azko-Nobel, Dow Chemical, PPG, TSI, Sherwin Williams and ToyoChem.
Two actions could have stopped the theft or lessened its impact:
- Real-time alerts and processes designed to prevent sensitive and protected data from exiting the corporate environment.
- Prohibiting personal and non-authorized electronic devices, including smartphones, from proximity to trade secrets or sensitive installations.
Using the smartphone’s camera to copy documents and workspace is a throwback technique of espionage days of old, when miniature and subminiature cameras would be used to copy documents from within restricted spaces. more
See Murray Associates - Recording in the Workplace Recommendations
Wednesday, March 17, 2021
Secret Recordings & a High Stakes Divorce
UK - A judge is overseeing a private divorce court hearing featuring a member of one of Britain's most famous business families and his estranged wife.
Sir Frederick Barclay, 86, and Lady Hiroko Barclay, 78, are both expected to give evidence at the virtual trial in the Family Division of the High Court...
The nephews - all sons of his twin brother David - allegedly made over 94 hours of secret recordings as part of what his lawyers have described as 'commercial espionage on a vast scale'. more | Some of the bugging video.
Saturday, January 23, 2021
Secret Recordings Reveal Sister's Sad Schadenfreude Shortcoming
via The New York Times...
My
sister revealed that she often records phone conversations that she has
with our father without his knowledge. She says she does it because he
is so “funny,” i.e., eccentric, but I get the impression that she is
laughing more at him than with him. I find his conversations less
humorous than distressing, since he is often, at the best of times, in a
state of heightened psychological dysregulation and anxiety, and the
pandemic has just made things worse. Because of my sister’s behavior, my
niece has grown up thinking there’s nothing wrong or unethical with
recording conversations without the other person’s knowledge or consent
and has herself started to do this.
|
When
I found out what my sister was doing, I was uneasy and told her that it
was illegal to record someone without their consent. Her rapid retort
was, “It’s not in New York,” where she lives, as if that made it OK. more |
Friday, November 6, 2020
Can Two-Party Consent to Record be Obtained Using a False Persona?
Massachusetts' top appellate court said it will review a case over whether a recorded telephone interview between a Barstool Sports podcast host and a local city mayor runs afoul of a law prohibiting secret recordings if one party fraudulently obtains consent for taping...
Having been denied an interview with Curtatone about the mayor's comments on the issue, Minihane tried again, this time claiming to be Boston Globe columnist Kevin Cullen, according to the suit. Minihane, posing as Cullen, was granted the interview, in which he told the mayor he was recording...
Barstool and Minihane's attorney Aaron Moss of Greenberg Glusker LLP said in a statement Thursday that he is confident the SJC will reject Curtatone's arguments and uphold the lower court's ruling.
"The Massachusetts Wiretap Act is crystal clear that it only prohibits secret recordings. If a recording isn't secret, the question of consent is irrelevant," Moss said. more
Interesting question. How would you decided?
Saturday, September 26, 2020
Extortionography: Executives Recorded Bragging of Cozy Government Relationships
Top executives hoping to blast open North America's largest gold and copper mine were secretly recorded describing in detail their cozy influence over US lawmakers and regulators.
They also revealed their intentions to go far beyond what they were saying on applications for federal permits to work near the headwaters of Bristol Bay, Alaska -- one of the last great wild salmon habitats left on Earth.
"I mean we can talk to the chief of staff of the White House any time we want, but you want to be careful with all this because it's all recorded," said Ron Thiessen, CEO of Northern Dynasty Minerals, of official communications to the White House, as he himself was recorded unknowingly. "You don't want to be seen to be trying to exercise undue influence." more
What is Extortionography? You need to know.
Friday, August 28, 2020
Open Mike Strikes Out
Cameras were rolling on the Mets' page of the MLB app Thursday afternoon and picked up a candid conversation from someone believed to be the Mets general manager.
"Baseball is trying to come up with a solution," the man says. "You know what would be super powerful?"
The man then pauses to tell the two people he's speaking to that this doesn't leave the room, unaware that the camera is rolling. more
Thursday, July 23, 2020
The World’s Smallest Voice Recorder?
Is this The World’s Smallest Voice Recorder?
TileRec by ATTO Digital Ultra-small: ≈1.53”x1.53”x.02” (≈39 x 39 x 5 mm)
Record modes: Voice activated or continuous.
Storage capacity: 145 hours.
Format: 128 kbps CD Quality MP3.
Playback: Download files to any computer.
Battery “on time”: Up to 24 hours.
Battery charge time: 2 hours.
Housing: Sturdy aluminum case.
Operates with one on/off switch.
Cost: $59.80 Amazon
A Voice Recorder Manufacturer Speaks
Jang Sung-Churl, chief executive of electronics firm Auto Jungbo Co. Ltd., told Reuters that covert recording devices “have been selling like hotcakes” …sales of voice recorders so far this year (2019) have doubled to 80 devices per day, Jang said as he forecast sales to also double this calendar year to 1.4 billion won ($1,172,289).Think about it. That's almost 30,000 devices sold per year... before the expected doubling of sales. And, he is only one manufacturer. An educated guess is that there are thousands of manufacturers around the world.
Who Cares About Voice Recorder Size?
- Sneaky people who want to eavesdrop.
- Sneaky people who want to entrap others.
- Anyone worried about covert surveillance.
- Local law enforcement detectives and Private Investigators. They might not have the budget necessary for a covert NAGRA Dollar Bill Recorder, but have the smarts to slap a TileRec between two one-dollar bills.
- Technical Surveillance Countermeasures (TSCM) Technicians whose job it is to find illegal, electronic surveillance devices.
People hiding voice recorders, and… thwarting the people doing it.
Discovering Voice Recorders
Since the offense has the advantage let’s concentrate on the defense.
In-Person Recording Detection Tips
- Since frisking is probably out of the question, assume you are being recorded. Even if you could frisk, results would be iffy; these voice recorders are tiny.
- At the outset of a conversation ask the other person if they are recording you. Watch their reaction. Do they overly protest, or fake anger? If they say no but record anyway, the recording’s value can be challenged. They lied, so maybe they also faked, edited or doctored the recording.
- Also… Be professional. If you would not say it in a courtroom, don’t say it.
Covert Recording Detection Tips
- Pay attention to your surroundings. Who has access and when? Voice recorders need to be retrieved: to review recordings and to recharge batteries.
- Avoid using the same area for all your sensitive conversations. Use various and unpredictable locations if possible.
- Conducting your own search for surveillance devices is futile. An experienced eavesdropper will plant one easy-to-find device. They know the search will stop at that point. The harder-to-find device and it’s back-up will still be on the job. Without proper training and instrumentation your success is unlikely.
- For office and home office situations an independent Technical Surveillance Countermeasures (TSCM) sweep team should be employed. Have them conduct periodic due diligence debugging inspections. In addition to searching for room audio and video surveillance devices have them check your vehicles. Vehicle inspections also include a search for GPS tracking devices.
TileRec Voice Recorder Detection Test
Testing Our Defenses
Conclusions
- The TileRec is (probably)
The World’s Smallest (affordable)
Voice Recorder (as of now). - Size doesn’t matter. Any mini recorder can be easily secreted and threaten privacy.
- The market for mini recorders is huge. There are a lot of them out there. Some of the very good ones are very inexpensive.
- Detection is difficult, but not impossible.
- The best self-protection tactic is watching what you say and situational awareness. Critical situations require the assistance of a professional TSCM / counterespionage firm.
Murray Associates is an independent counterespionage consulting firm, providing eavesdropping detection (TSCM) and counterespionage services to business, government and the at-risk individual.
Thursday, June 18, 2020
Is Your Hotel or AirBnB Spying on You?
Have you ever plugged your phone into the USB of an alarm clock and said, “I’m so glad this hotel or guest house made my life easier with this bedside technology!”?
Have you ever looked up at a smoke detector and said, “Thank god that’s there in case of a fire, I’ll be protected!”?
Well, here’s some bad news: all of those items can be, and possibly are, hidden cameras that are watching you, recording you, spying on you, and violating you. And the worst part, these disguised cameras are only sometimes illegal.
Don’t believe us? Do a simple Amazon search and prepare to be frightened by the amount of spying equipment you can get two-day shipping on. There are hidden cameras in wall outlets, clocks, picture frames, clothes hooks, pens, and so much more. more
Learn how to detect covert spy cameras.