via Wired Magazine...
Years ago, while stationed
in Moscow as the bureau chief for a major news magazine, I was
approached by a representative of a multinational company and presented
with a tantalizing offer. He said he had highly sensitive materials
exposing possible criminal activity by a Russian competitor. The
documents were mine with one condition: advance notice so he could be
out of the country when any story was published.
I
had every reason to think the materials came from a private
intelligence operative hired by the company—there were many such
operatives in Moscow—but I didn’t ask my source for his source. Instead I
embarked on a somewhat harrowing investigation of my own, and on
corroborating the materials, I was able to publish a splashy story.
This episode came back to me while reading Barry Meier’s new book,
Spooked: The Trump Dossier, Black Cube, and the Rise of Private Spies. A former
New York Times
investigative reporter, Meier casts a harsh light on both “private
spies” and journalists who make frequent use of nuggets unearthed by
these operatives. In the book’s afterword, he revives an idea for “a
kind of ‘spy registry’ in which operatives for hire would have to
disclose the names of their clients and assignments,” just as Congress
now requires of lobbyists hired to influence legislators.
Is this truly a problem in need of a solution? Or would a spy registry create worse problems?
It’s tempting to conclude that there is really
nothing new here and that private spies may even supply a public
service. In the original, late-19th-century Gilded Age, the Pinkerton
Detective Agency devoted itself to the art of subterfuge. In 1890, a
Pinkerton man went undercover on behalf of his client, the governor of
North Dakota, and confirmed from rigorous barroom investigation that a
fair amount of “boodle,” bribe money, was being dispensed by advocates
of a state lottery opposed by the governor. The governor revealed the
dirty dealings to the public, and the lottery scheme failed—all perhaps
to the civic good.
Today’s
circumstances are far different. Inexpensive, off-the-shelf
technologies for surveillance, hacking, and spoofing make the spy game
easier to play than ever before. What hired sleuth doesn’t now travel
with one of those metallic-fabric bags that blocks cellphone GPS
signals, like the GoDark Faraday model that sells online for $49.97?
It’s an insignificant item on the expense report. more